New laws in New South Wales are changing how character references can be used in criminal sentencing. These reforms have sparked debate about fairness and justice in the legal system.
What’s Changing?
Under the changes, NSW Courts will face stricter guidelines when considering character references, particularly in serious criminal cases.
The changes aim to address concerns that glowing testimonials from employers, community leaders, and family members have historically benefited privileged offenders while disadvantaged defendants who lack similar networks to provide such letters.
Why Some Support the Changes
Supporters say the reforms help level the playing field:
-
Fairness: Wealthy or well-connected offenders have often been able to provide glowing references from prominent people, potentially swaying outcomes in their favour while those from lower socio-economic backgrounds, Indigenous communities, or without established professional networks rarely have access to such endorsements.
-
Perspective: Character references only highlight the offender’s positive qualities and can leave out past behaviour that may be important.
-
Victim impact: Some victims report feeling distressed when they hear highly positive letters read out in court about the person who harmed them.
By limiting character references, the reforms aim to ensure sentences focus more on the actual offence.
Why Others Are Concerned
Critics believe the new limits may remove helpful information from the Courts striping valuable context from sentencing process:
-
Understanding the person: Character references can show genuine efforts to change, community involvement, or personal challenges that explain how someone ended up before the court.
-
Judicial discretion: Judges and magistrates traditionally consider the whole person, not just the crime when deciding the most appropriate sentence.
-
Not all references are privileged: Many come from teachers, coaches, counsellors, social workers, and others working closely with everyday people.
The concern is that removing these insights may make sentencing less personalised.
What This Means for Defendants
If you are facing sentence, you may no longer be able to rely heavily on character references. Defendants will now need stronger, more structured evidence to show their background, behaviour, and any steps they have taken to turn things around.
This may include:
-
Reports showing participation in rehabilitation programs
-
Psychological assessments
-
Employment records or training certificates
-
Expert evidence where needed
Because the rules are changing, having an experienced solicitor is now more important than ever. A skilled advocate can identify what evidence the court will accept and present your case in the strongest possible way.
If you need legal advice or representation for a driving or criminal matter, our experienced team is here to help.